Fried catfish with cornmeal crust, hushpuppies and coleslaw is one of the best-known meals of the Mid-South, and almost all of it these days comes from fish raised in ponds rather than caught in rivers. That change has a history, and Arkansas sits near the start of it. This guide explains how farm-raised catfish took off, why the fish fry remains a community event, and what to look for when you sit down at a catfish restaurant.
From rivers to ponds
Long before there was a catfish industry, catfish were pulled from streams and rivers from the Arkansas hills to the Delta and cooked for large gatherings. The fish fry grew out of that practice, and according to At Home Arkansas it remains a source of community and camaraderie today.
The Encyclopedia of Arkansas describes the state as the birthplace of the commercial catfish industry. At least two farms were selling fish in the late 1950s. During the 1960s growers shifted from raising buffalofish to catfish, and by 1966 the state had several thousand acres in production and three processing plants. The early years were not smooth. Catfish were treated much like a row crop, stocked in spring and harvested in the fall, which left processing plants without steady supply for much of the year. A mid-1970s downturn followed rising fishmeal costs, an economic recession and the lack of year-round production methods. Multiple-batch production in the 1980s solved the supply problem by keeping plants supplied through the year. Arkansas was the starting point; the Mississippi Delta later became the center of production for the industry.
What a fish fry looks like
A traditional fish fry has a predictable shape. Fillets or whole fish are coated in seasoned cornmeal and fried in hot oil until crisp. They are served with hushpuppies, which are balls of fried cornmeal batter, with coleslaw, tartar sauce or hot sauce, and with sides that can include fries, beans, greens or fried okra. The meal is informal and meant for groups, which is why many catfish restaurants also offer all-you-can-eat plates.
Farm-raised versus Gulf seafood
It helps to know the difference between a catfish house and a coastal seafood restaurant. Catfish is a freshwater fish, mild and slightly sweet, and its cornmeal crust is part of the dish. A Gulf Coast restaurant such as Felix's Fish Camp, on Mobile Bay in Spanish Fort, Alabama, builds its menu around saltwater fish, shrimp, crab and oysters, along with gumbo, crab soup and turtle soup. Both are Southern seafood traditions, but they are different, and a restaurant can be excellent at one and unremarkable at the other.
Catfish in our directory
Ed's Catfish & BBQ at 2512 East Highland Drive in Jonesboro specializes in fried catfish and barbecue. It reports six wins in the regional Best of NEA poll, offers plates and an all-you-can-eat option, and lists takeout and delivery. Listings show it open Tuesday to Saturday, 11 AM to 8:30 PM, and closed Sunday and Monday, so confirm by phone at (870) 932-0710. Ed's is a good place to see how a catfish restaurant combines two traditions, because the barbecue and the fish fry share the same menu.
Judy's Place in Mobile, Alabama, is a Southern restaurant rather than a catfish house, but it shows the neighboring tradition: shrimp and grits, fried crab claws, chicken and dumplings and a burger made with Conecuh sausage, a smoked sausage from south Alabama.
Ordering tips
- Ask for fillets or whole fish. Many places offer both, and whole fish has more flavor and more bones.
- Do not skip the hushpuppies. They are meant to be eaten with the fish, and a good kitchen makes them fresh.
- Check the buffet's timing. An all-you-can-eat catfish buffet is best at the start of a meal service, when the first fish comes out of the fryer.
- Look at the hours. Many small catfish restaurants close on Sunday and Monday, and some close in mid-afternoon between lunch and dinner.
Menus, hours and prices change. Each restaurant page shows the phone number we hold; call before a long drive, especially around holidays.