"Barbecue" means different things depending on where you are standing. In the American South and Southwest it usually means meat cooked slowly, for hours, over low heat and wood smoke, rather than grilled quickly over high heat. Beyond that shared idea, almost everything changes from one region to the next: the animal, the cut, the wood, the rub and above all the sauce. This guide walks through the traditions most often named, explains the vocabulary you will meet on a menu, and then shows where four restaurants in our directory sit in that picture.
The idea behind it: low heat, long time
Tough, collagen-rich cuts such as pork shoulder, beef brisket and ribs reward patient cooking. Held at a low temperature for many hours, the connective tissue breaks down into gelatin, which is why a good brisket slices tenderly and a good pork shoulder pulls apart with a fork. Smoke from burning hardwood adds flavor, and the type of wood matters: hickory, oak, pecan and mesquite are all common, and each gives a different character. Many pitmasters add a dry rub of salt, pepper, paprika and other spices before cooking, and a sauce either during cooking or at the table.
The four styles people usually name
The Carolinas: pork and vinegar
The Carolinas are often described as home to one of the oldest barbecue traditions in the country, built around pork that is pulled or chopped. In North Carolina the sauce is typically thin and vinegar-based with pepper, while South Carolina is best known for its own sauce styles, including a mustard-based one. The meat is the point; the sauce adds tang rather than sweetness.
Memphis: ribs and the dry-or-wet choice
Memphis barbecue is centered on pork, especially ribs and pulled shoulder. Many places serve ribs "dry", seasoned with a spice rub and no sauce, with sauce on the side, or "wet", brushed with a tomato-based sauce. Ordering dry or wet is part of the ritual. The city also sits at the edge of the Mississippi Delta, so it blends influences from several directions. Our directory also includes the The Arcade Restaurant, a diner that has served South Main Street since 1919, though it is known for breakfast rather than barbecue.
Kansas City: sweet sauce and burnt ends
Kansas City draws on both pork and beef and is known for a thick, sweet, tomato-based sauce. Its signature item is burnt ends, the fatty, caramelized pieces cut from the point of a brisket. Food historians commonly credit Henry Perry, a Memphis native who moved to Kansas City in the early 1900s, with opening the city's first commercial barbecue business around 1907, which is why Kansas City is often described as a meeting point of Southern pork and Texas beef.
Texas: beef, brisket and restraint
In Texas the star is beef brisket, and in the central part of the state the seasoning can be as simple as salt and black pepper, with smoke doing most of the work. Sauce is often optional or served on the side. Texas is frequently placed at the western end of a wider "barbecue belt" that runs across the South.
Beyond the big four
Barbecue historian Robert F. Moss has argued that four styles are only a starting point, because many areas inside the barbecue belt have their own traditions. A well-known example is Alabama white sauce. According to the Encyclopedia of Alabama, a railroad worker named Bob Gibson began selling barbecued chicken from a backyard shack in Decatur in the early 1920s and served it with a sauce of mayonnaise, vinegar and black pepper. The usual explanation for the mayonnaise is practical: slow-roasted chicken can dry out, and the fatty, tangy sauce keeps it moist. Other versions add lemon juice, horseradish or cayenne. Sources disagree on whether 1925 marks the backyard business or the restaurant, so treat the exact date with care.
How to order at a barbecue counter
- Meat is often sold by weight. A quarter-pound or half-pound per person is a common starting point, with sides on the side.
- Ask about lean and fatty brisket. In Texas-style places, "moist" or "fatty" brisket comes from the point and "lean" from the flat. Many people ask for a mix.
- Sauce on the side lets you taste the meat first. A cook who is proud of the smoke will not mind.
- Go before the rush. Small barbecue restaurants can run out of popular cuts late in the day, because the cooking is done in advance and cannot be hurried.
- Do not judge by the pink ring alone. A smoke ring is a chemical effect of the cooking process and is not a measure of flavor.
Four barbecue restaurants in our directory
Bobby-Q in Phoenix opened in 2005 and cooks over wood with a house dry rub. Its menu lets a table compare three rib styles side by side: St. Louis, baby back and Texas beef ribs. Meals start with homemade cornbread, and there is a steak side to the menu too.
Joe's Real BBQ in Gilbert, Arizona, smokes meat over Arizona pecan wood in a style the restaurant describes as Texas-influenced with Kansas City touches. It opened in 1998 in a building that dates to 1929, and the notable items include pit ham and a turkey-jalapeno sausage.
Ed's Catfish & BBQ in Jonesboro, Arkansas, pairs barbecue with fried catfish, which is a regional combination rather than a single style. Plates and an all-you-can-eat option are both listed.
T's BBQ in Harrison, Arkansas, describes its cooking as Arkansas-style barbecue. Ordering pages list a Beef Brisket Plate and a Half Slab Plate, and reviews are mixed, which is a useful reminder that barbecue is a matter of taste as well as technique.
Menus, hours and prices change. Each restaurant page shows the phone number we hold; call before a long drive, especially around holidays.